The Beale Ciphers: Virginia’s Modern-Day DaVinci Code

Beale ciphers
Legend has it that Thomas Beale and his band of adventurers discovered a treasure cache in the American Southwest

As a boy, I was fascinated by tales of lost treasure: The Hardy Boy’s Tower Treasure, Stephenson’s Treasure Island, and Poe’s The Gold Bug. Stories of long-lost fortunes conjure images of daring quests, secret maps, and the intoxicating possibility of striking it rich. Such tales are everywhere. Their allure taps into our innate desire for discovery and the excitement of the unknown.

The Thomas Beale Treasure

Imagine, then, my fascination when I learned of the Thomas Beale treasure, allegedly buried in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains in 1822, complete with a cryptic code book to guide treasure seekers to its location. This isn’t a tale from an adventure novel but a real-life mystery that has captivated treasure hunters for over a century. The Beale ciphers, a set of encoded messages, allegedly point to a fortune in gold, silver, and jewels hidden by Thomas J. Beale two hundred years ago. Are these ciphers the key to a legendary treasure or simply an elaborate hoax? Dive into the enigma of the Beale treasure and decide for yourself: is this mystery fact, fiction, or a bit of both?

Thomas Jefferson Beale and His Mysterious Journey

Let’s step back to the early 1800s, when America was still a young nation, and the frontier was teeming with opportunity and adventure. Enter Thomas J. Beale, a man whose name would become synonymous with one of the greatest treasure mysteries in history. Little is known about Beale’s early life, but what makes him legendary is his supposed discovery of a massive fortune.

According to the story, Beale and a group of fellow adventurers stumbled upon a cache of gold and silver while exploring the wilds of the American Southwest. Imagine the excitement of uncovering such wealth in a remote and uncharted land. This was no small stash—a treasure worth millions by today’s standards.

Beale, thinking ahead, decided to transport this treasure to a secure location. He chose the picturesque hills of Bedford County, Virginia (between Roanoke and Lynchburg) as the hiding spot. To ensure the treasure’s safety and future retrieval, he devised an elaborate plan to encrypt the treasure’s location in a series of ciphers. And so, the legend of the Beale treasure began.

The Creation of the Beale Ciphers

Now, let’s talk about those famous ciphers. Beale didn’t just jot down a simple map or leave obvious clues. No, he created three intricate ciphers. These were essentially coded messages that held the secrets to the treasure’s location, the inventory of its contents, and the names of those who were meant to inherit this fortune.

The first cipher describes the location of the treasure. This is the big one—the key to finding the hidden gold and silver. However, to this day, it remains undeciphered, a compelling puzzle that has stumped cryptographers and treasure hunters alike.

The second cipher, which has been decoded, lists the contents of the treasure: gold, silver, and jewels. Just reading the inventory could make a treasure hunter’s heart race with the thought of such wealth hidden away, waiting to be discovered.

The third cipher contains the names of the treasure’s intended beneficiaries. This puzzle piece adds a personal touch to the mystery, suggesting that Beale wanted his friends or family to benefit from this incredible find.

Beale entrusted these ciphers to his friend, Robert Morriss, the innkeeper of Washington Hotel in Lynchburg, Virginia. Along with the ciphers, Beale left a letter instructing Morriss to open the box containing them if he or his men did not return within ten years. True to Beale’s instructions, Morriss waited and opened the box when Beale and his men never returned. He tried to decode the ciphers for years but only managed to crack the second one.

Beale ciphers
Only the second of the three Beale ciphers has been decoded.

Attempts to Solve the Beale Ciphers

In the following decades, numerous amateur and professional codebreakers have tried their hand at the ciphers. Cipher Two’s decryption story is particularly intriguing; it was decoded using the Declaration of Independence as a key, where each number in the cipher corresponded to a word in the document. However, this success only deepened the mystery, as Cipher One, the location cipher, has resisted all similar methods.

Modern Approaches and Technology

With technological advancements, modern-day treasure hunters have applied sophisticated tools to crack the Beale ciphers. Computer algorithms and complex statistical analyses have been used in attempts to find patterns or hidden keys within the texts. Some have turned to advanced cryptographic techniques, while others have used historical documents, hoping to find a key that fits.

Despite these efforts, Cipher One remains unsolved. This persistent mystery continues to draw new enthusiasts and experts into its fold, each armed with the latest technology and a fresh perspective. Artificial intelligence and machine learning represent the cutting edge of current attempts, yet the ciphers remain an enigma.

Theories and Speculation

The Hoax Theory

One of the most debated aspects of the Beale ciphers is whether they are genuine or an elaborate hoax. Skeptics argue that the ciphers could be a fabrication, possibly created by James B. Ward, who first published the Beale Papers in 1885. They point to inconsistencies in the story and a lack of concrete evidence supporting the existence of Beale and his treasure.

Supporters of the hoax theory suggest that Ward, or someone else, concocted the tale to sell books or attract attention. They highlight the absence of verifiable records of Beale or his associates and the improbability of such a vast treasure remaining hidden for so long.

The Authenticity Theory

On the other hand, many believe in the authenticity of the Beale ciphers and the treasure. They argue that the decoded Cipher Two, detailing the treasure’s inventory, lends credibility to the story. Proponents of this theory also point to the detailed and consistent nature of the Beale Papers as evidence that the story might be true.

Believers continue to search for the key to Cipher One, convinced that the treasure is real and still out there, waiting to be discovered. The legend has inspired countless treasure hunts and has become a part of local folklore.

Beale treasure location
The Beale treasure is said to be buried in Bedford County, Virginia

My Two Cents on the Beale Ciphers

Forever a romantic, I still prefer to think there’s a treasure buried somewhere in Bedford County. However, I’m not going to look for it. Over the years, my treasure hunting has been confined to being self-employed. But I am fascinated with the idea of buried treasure and treasure hunters. Each new generation of treasure hunters brings fresh energy and ideas, keeping the hunt alive. Stories of daring adventures and near-miss discoveries abound, adding to the legend’s richness.

The Beale ciphers, with their compelling promise of hidden riches, have become a symbol of the quest for knowledge and the thrill of the unknown. Whether viewed as an unsolved cryptographic puzzle or a legendary treasure hunt, their legacy continues to captivate and inspire.


Leave a Reply