A Letter from Mother Jones to the Miners of Cabin Creek

Reading Time: 6 minutes

Editor’s Note:

The following is a fictionalized letter inspired by Mary Harris Jones (Mother Jones) real-life words and activism. While this letter is imagined, the events it describes—the brutality of the Paint Creek and Cabin Creek strike, the suffering of the miners, and the role of labor in America—are deeply rooted in history. An opposing perspective and commentary follow the letter.

To the Brave Miners of Paint Creek and Cabin Creek,

You have been cast out of your homes. Your children cry for bread while the coal barons sit in their fine houses, warmed by the very fuel you ripped from the belly of these mountains. You ask for a fair wage, and they send gun thugs to drive you into the dirt. But hear me now, my boys—they may have their guns, their money, their bought-and-paid-for lawmen, but they do not have your spirit.

I have walked among you, through the tent colonies where your wives boil potatoes over open fires and your little ones sleep wrapped in rags. I have seen the blood on your faces when Baldwin-Felts goons fire their rifles into your camps, trying to break you with fear. But I have also seen something far greater. I have seen men who will not be broken.

The True Cause of This Fight

Let no one twist the truth of why you have taken to the picket line. You did not strike for luxury—you struck for fairness.

For years, the mine operators paid you $2.50 a day for the backbreaking work of tearing coal from the earth. They paid your wages in scrip, forcing you to spend every cent in their overpriced company stores, where a pound of meat costs three times what it does in town.

They ruled your homes—company houses that you could be thrown from at a moment’s notice. They ruled your lives—blacklisting any man who dared speak out. They even ruled your deaths—forcing your families to buy coffins from the company when the mines caved in, as they so often do.

And when the Kanawha miners won their wage increase, the operators here refused to give you the same. You asked for $2.50 in real U.S. currency, a fair scale, and the right to organize so that a miner could not be fired at a coal boss’s whim.

For this, they called you criminals. For this, they threw your families into the cold. For this, they sent in armed men to drive you into submission.

The Greedy Hands of the Coal Operators

The men who run these mines—they do not know you. They have never seen the black dust settle into the lines of a man’s face, never coughed it from their lungs, never buried a brother in a wooden box after the roof of a shaft gave way. They sit in Charleston, in New York, drinking their fine whiskey while you claw coal from the earth for a pittance. And yet they call you criminals, lawbreakers, anarchists—because you dared to ask for a living wage.

They say they own the coal, the land, the railroads. But tell me this—who built those mines? Who laid those tracks? Who sweated and bled and died so that they could grow rich? It was you. It has always been you. Capital and labor are two sides of the same coin. One doesn’t work without the other.

Stand Fast, Stand Together

This 1912 coal war is not a fight for a few cents more a day—it is a fight for the right to live as men, not as slaves. Do not waver. Do not break. They will come at you with more guns, more soldiers, more threats of hunger. But you hold the line.

You are not alone. Across this country, men and women stand with you. The steelworkers of Pittsburgh, the textile women of Massachusetts, the railroad men who keep this country moving—they are watching. Your fight is their fight. And when we stand together, we are an army mightier than any Baldwin-Felts gunman, mightier than any coal boss.

A Warning to the Coal Barons

I have a message for those who would grind you under their heel:

Your hired thugs can burn the miners’ tents, but you will never burn the idea that a workingman should earn his due. You can jail the leaders, but you cannot jail the movement. You can kill the men, but you cannot kill the fight for justice.

And make no mistake—justice will come.

So, I say to you, coal operators, Baldwin-Felts detectives, company men who think yourselves untouchable: Look around you. You build your fortunes on the backs of the men you starve. But even the mightiest oak can be felled when the people rise up with their axes.

A Final Word to the Miners

My boys, they will call you troublemakers. They will call you lawless. But the only law that matters is the one written on your hearts—that no man should starve while another grows fat from his labor.

Stand together. Hold fast. This struggle will not be won in a day, nor in a week, but it will be won. And when that day comes, when the guns are silent, and the mine gates open to men paid fairly for their work, know this: it was you who won it.

Until then, I stand with you. I fight with you. And if they call me an agitator, a troublemaker, a dangerous old woman, so be it. I would rather die a fighter than live as a coward.

Yours in battle,
Mother Jones

The Coal Operators’ Perspective

To the coal operators, the Coal War of 1912 was not just a labor dispute—it was a fight for survival in an industry plagued by falling coal prices, rising costs, and fierce competition. Many mine owners had poured their fortunes into developing operations in the rugged hills of West Virginia, building rail lines, company towns, and supply chains that were costly to maintain.

With contracts to fulfill and investors to appease, they saw the strike not as a call for justice but as a direct threat to their ability to stay afloat. Union demands for higher wages and independent housing challenged the very foundation of their business model, one built on tight control of labor, company-owned stores, and scrip-based economies. To them, giving in to the strikers’ demands meant setting a precedent that could spread to other mines, weaken company control, and collapse already fragile profit margins. Faced with this pressure, they turned to armed guards, political allies, and martial law to protect what they saw as their rightful claim to the industry they had built—no matter the cost.

Why This Story Still Matters

The coal war of 1912 wasn’t just a moment in history—it was a turning point in the fight for workers’ rights. Mother Jones was real, and her words, her fury, and her relentless defiance against the coal operators were no less powerful than the bullets that flew in the hills of West Virginia.

The struggle Mother Jones fought then still echoes today. Across the country, workers continue to battle for fair wages, safe conditions, and the right to unionize. The tools of conflict may have changed—court rulings, corporate lobbying, technology that tracks and controls workers—but the fight remains the same.

I see some truth on both sides of the conflict. One thing is sure: the violence didn’t help. The strength of labor is not in defiance alone but in the power to sit at the table as equals with capital. The mines, the factories, the railroads — none of them run without workers’ hands, and workers don’t survive without the investment and risk of capital. For capitalism to endure and prosper, there must be a hard-won balance where labor has a voice and capital has the wisdom to listen. Collective bargaining is not an obstacle to progress; it is the safeguard that keeps the system honest, fair, and sustainable for all.

---